Contents
At a glanceSide-by-side comparisonControlComfort and acceptanceSafetyUsing bothOur verdictFAQsWhen your dog drags you down the road, the two most common fixes trainers suggest are a head collar and a no pull harness. Both redirect your dog when they pull, but they do it from different ends. One steers the head. The other turns the chest. Both can help, but they suit different dogs and different owners. Each has fans among trainers.
This comparison looks at control, comfort, how long each takes to introduce and which dogs suit which. In short, many owners try a harness first and add a head collar for very strong dogs. Training a loose lead still does the real work. Both are affordable, so trying each is not a big risk. Read on for the detail. Here is the detail.
At a glance
Head collar



Popular choices include the Premier Black Head Collar (£16.77), Halti Headcollar Black Head Collar (£8.35) and Halti Headcollar Blue Head Collar (£9.50).
See the whole head collars range.
No pull harness



Popular choices include the Double Clip Harness, No Pull Vest with (£16.12), JULIUS-K9 Black No Pull Harness (£21.79) and PetSafe No Pull Harness (£14.99).
See the whole no pull harnesses range.
Side-by-side comparison
| Feature | Head collar | No pull harness |
|---|---|---|
| Steers from | Nose and head | Chest |
| Control on strong dogs | Very high | High |
| Introduction time | Days to weeks | Usually quick |
| Short-nosed breeds | Not suitable | Suitable |
| Risk if jerked | Neck strain | Low |
| Wear with collar | Yes, for ID | Yes, for ID |
| Typical price | Low | Low to mid |
Control
A head collar gives powerful steering because it turns the head, and the body follows. Small owners with big dogs often feel the difference straight away. A front clip harness turns the dog sideways when they pull, which takes the fun out of surging forward. It is gentler but slightly less powerful. For most dogs, the harness gives enough control for everyday walks. That makes it a good first choice.
Comfort and acceptance
Most dogs accept a harness quickly. Head collars need careful introduction with treats, and some dogs never like them. A dog rubbing its face on the ground every few steps is not having a good walk. Most dogs barely notice a harness after a few walks. A head collar needs more patience, but plenty of dogs come to accept it with careful introduction and lots of treats. Watch your dog's body language to judge how they feel.
Safety
Never jerk a head collar, as it can twist the neck. A harness is more forgiving of mistakes. Head collars are not suitable for flat-faced breeds. Head collars need a light hand, because they control the head and a sudden yank can twist the neck. Pugs, French Bulldogs and other short-nosed breeds have nowhere for the nose band to sit, so a harness is the safer choice for them. Always keep a backup clip to the collar or harness.
Using both
Some owners use a harness and head collar together with a double ended lead. The harness carries the main load, and the head collar is there for steering in tricky moments. This set-up suits big, strong dogs and smaller owners. A double ended lead lets you hold both clips in one hand. As your dog learns to walk nicely, you can drop the head collar and keep the harness, or keep both for tricky situations.
Our verdict
Try a well fitted Y-front no pull harness first. It suits nearly every dog and is easy to introduce.
If you need more control, add a head collar and introduce it slowly. Either way, reward a loose lead every time, and ask a trainer for help if pulling comes with lunging or barking.
Prefer to browse everything? Our full ranges of head collars and no pull harnesses have more sizes, finishes and price points than we could fit here.
Frequently asked questions
Can I use a head collar on a puppy?
Most trainers suggest a light harness for puppies and leave head collars for older dogs if needed. Puppies have growing necks and are still learning to walk on a lead. Start with a light harness and plenty of treats.
Do head collars hurt dogs?
Not when fitted well and used gently. Jerking the lead can strain the neck. Some dogs find them uncomfortable at first, so introduce one slowly and watch for signs of stress. Never jerk the lead.
Will a no pull harness work on a big dog?
For many big dogs, yes. Very strong dogs may need a head collar as well. Fit matters a lot with big dogs. Make sure every strap is snug and the chest ring sits centred. Keep training alongside it.
Which is better for a reactive dog?
A secure harness is usually the start. Talk to a behaviourist about whether a head collar would help or add stress. Reactive dogs can find a head collar uncomfortable when they lunge. A secure harness is usually a better start while you work on the cause.