Both give your dog more room than a standard lead, and both are popular. But ask a group of trainers and most will lean towards the long line. The reason is the spring inside a retractable lead, which keeps a slight pull on the dog at all times. Both have their place. There are good reasons for that, and a few cases where a retractable makes sense. Here is why, in plain terms.
This comparison looks at control, training, safety and convenience, so you can choose the right tool for your walks. We explain where each fits, so you can use the right lead on the right walk. Both tools can earn a place in your walking bag. The trick is knowing which one suits each walk. Read on for the detail. Here is how they compare.
At a glance
Long line



Popular choices include the Toozey 20m And Longer Line (£8.16), Training Long Training Line (£11.49) and Training Long Training Line, 15m Nylon Long Line (£13.49).
See the whole long training lines range.
Retractable lead



Popular choices include the TUG 25kg Black Retractable Lead (£15.99), TUG 25kg Blue Retractable Lead (£15.99) and TUG 25kg White LED Dog Lead (£15.99).
See the whole retractable leads range.
Side-by-side comparison
| Feature | Long line | Retractable lead |
|---|---|---|
| Length | 5 to 30 metres | 3 to 8 metres |
| Tension on dog | None when slack | Constant light pull |
| Recall training | Excellent | Limited |
| Pavements | Awkward | Handy if locked short |
| Injury risk | Rope burn if wrapped | Cord burns, handle drops |
| Attach to | Harness | Harness |
| Price | Low to mid | Low to mid |
Training
A long line lies loose on the ground, so your dog learns that a slack line is normal. That is perfect for recall practice. A retractable lead always has a little pull, which can teach a dog that pulling earns more lead. Over time, a dog on a long line learns to stay within range and check in with you, which is the foundation of good recall. A retractable lead is handy, but it does not build those habits in the same way.
Convenience
Retractables are tidy and quick in the street. Long lines need gathering and can tangle. For a short town walk, a retractable locked at a short length is easy. A long line takes more effort to handle, especially in woods or around other walkers. You need to gather loops and watch for tangles. Retractables are quick and tidy, which is why so many owners use them for short walks around the block.
Safety
Thin retractable cords can cause burns if they wrap round legs. Dropped handles can clatter behind a dog and scare it. Long lines can burn hands if wrapped round fingers. Gloves help. The thin cord on many retractables can cause nasty burns if it wraps round a leg or a finger. If the handle is dropped, it can chase a scared dog. Long lines can tangle and burn hands too. Wear gloves and never wrap any lead round your fingers.
Where each fits
Use a long line in parks and fields while building recall. A retractable is fine on quiet paths for a dog that already walks well. Neither should be used near traffic at full length. Use a long line for training sessions in open spaces where your dog can explore safely. Use a retractable only on quiet paths and only with a dog that walks calmly. Near roads, lock any lead short.
Our verdict
For training and freedom in open spaces, a long line wins.
A retractable lead is a convenience tool for calm dogs on quiet paths. Keep it locked short near roads.
Prefer to browse everything? Our full ranges of long training lines and retractable leads have more sizes, finishes and price points than we could fit here.
Frequently asked questions
Why do trainers dislike retractable leads?
The constant tension can reward pulling, and cord injuries happen. The constant pull from the spring can teach a dog that pulling earns more length. There is also a risk of cord injuries. Long lines avoid both.
What length long line should I buy?
10 metres suits most dogs to start. A 10 metre line suits most dogs and owners to start. Move to longer lines once you are confident handling them in open fields. Small dogs suit shorter lines.
Can I use a long line in the woods?
Yes, but it tangles more. A shorter line suits woodland. You can, but it tangles more easily round trees and bushes. A shorter line of 5 metres is easier to manage in woodland. Watch for snags.
Should either go on a collar?
No. Clip both to a harness. No. Clip both to a well fitted harness. A sudden stop at the end of either lead can jar the neck, while a harness spreads the force across the chest.