Kind training gear, legal in every UK nation

Home / Blog / Best PetSafe Spray Bark Collar Alternatives (UK)

Alternatives

Best PetSafe Spray Bark Collar Alternatives (UK)

By the Collarwise team · Updated November 2026

ContentsAbout the PetSafe Spray Bark Control CollarAlternatives at a glanceDetectionRefillsSizeKind useThe alternativesFAQs

PetSafe's spray bark collar is one of the best-known no-shock bark collars in the UK. It uses a burst of citronella or unscented spray when it detects barking. If you want to compare it with other spray collars, perhaps cheaper ones or ones with different refills, this guide is for you. Plenty of other brands make similar collars. It is a familiar name in UK pet shops.

We also cover how to use any spray collar alongside reward training, and when barking needs a behaviourist instead. Every collar here is a spray model with no static function, so it is legal across the UK. We focus on detection, refills, sizing and how to use any of them kindly. Refill costs are covered too. Each pick costs the same or less.

About the PetSafe Spray Bark Control Collar

PetSafe Spray Bark Control Collar by PetSafe · typically around £60.00

The PetSafe Spray Bark Control Collar is an automatic bark collar that releases a short spray of citronella or unscented spray when it detects barking. It uses refill cans and is sold widely in the UK. Prices vary.

Alternatives at a glance

Detection

Compare how each collar detects barking. Sensors that feel vibration in the throat cut false triggers. Some collars use only a microphone, which can be set off by other dogs or loud noises. Better models use a sensor that feels vibration in the throat as well. Compare how each detects a bark, and look for adjustable sensitivity to cut false sprays. Test it at home. Fewer false sprays means less confusion.

Refills

Check refill price, availability and whether a cheaper collar uses a common valve. Refills are the hidden cost of any spray collar. Check the price of a can, how many sprays it gives and whether the valve fits other brands. A cheap collar with expensive or hard-to-find refills may cost more in the long run. Do the sums before you buy, and keep a spare can handy. Refill costs add up over months.

Size

Look at minimum neck size and weight, especially for small dogs. Look at the minimum neck size and weight on each listing. Small dogs need light units with narrow straps. Large dogs need a strap long enough to fit snugly high on the neck, where the sensor can work properly. Measure before you order, as a poor fit means the collar may not work. Check the strap length. Check the strap length too.

Kind use

Use any spray collar for short periods, reward quiet and stop if your dog seems frightened. Use any spray collar for short periods only, ideally while you are there to watch. Reward quiet behaviour and give your dog plenty of exercise and things to do. Stop if your dog seems frightened, and speak to a behaviourist if barking continues. Your dog's welfare comes first. Your dog's comfort and trust come first.

The alternatives

PetSafe Remote Spray Training Collar
Closest match

1.PetSafe Remote Spray Training Collar

★★★★☆4.2 (3,309)
£13.99 save about £46.01

This is the one we would point most people to for closest match. 3,309 buyers rate it 4.2 out of 5. £13.99, one of the cheaper options here. Have a look at the PetSafe Remote Spray Training Collar for the full spec.

What we likeAnti-Bark Spray Refill
300-400 Jets
Eco Formula
Worth knowingRatings a little lower than the top picks

Compare it with the rest of our citronella bark collars.

Anti Bark Small Dog Spray Collar, Anti Barking Dog Colla
Best value

2.Anti Bark Small Dog Spray Collar, Anti Barking Dog Colla

★★★★☆4.5 (74)
£33.99 save about £26.01

This is the one we would point most people to for value. Rated 4.5 out of 5. £33.99, one of the cheaper options here. Have a look at the Anti Bark Small Dog Spray Collar, Anti Barking Dog Colla for the full spec.

What we likeAuto Citronella Dog Collar Stop Barking
Citronella Bark Collar with 3 Adjustable Sensitivity & Spray Levels
Anti Barking Dog Colla
Worth knowingCheck dimensions against your space before ordering

If it is not quite right, we stock plenty more citronella bark collars.

Citronella Small Dog Spray Collar
Best unscented

3.Citronella Small Dog Spray Collar

★★★★★4.8 (77)
£39.99 save about £20.01

This is the one we would point most people to for unscented. Rated 4.8 out of 5. £39.99, so you pay a bit more for the spec. Have a look at the Citronella Small Dog Spray Collar for the full spec.

What we like5 Modes & Levels
No Spray Refill
Worth knowingCheck dimensions against your space before ordering

There are other options in our citronella bark collars range too.

Citronella Small Dog Spray Collar, 5 Modes & Levels
Best for small dogs

4.Citronella Small Dog Spray Collar, 5 Modes & Levels

★★★★★4.8 (77)
£49.99 save about £10.01

Citronella Small Dog Spray Collar, 5 Modes & Levels is our pick for for small dogs. Rated 4.8 out of 5. £49.99, so you pay a bit more for the spec. You can see the full specs and photos on the Citronella Small Dog Spray Collar, 5 Modes & Levels page.

What we like5 Modes & Levels
1*Spray Refill
Worth knowingCosts more than most options here

Compare it with the rest of our citronella bark collars.

Anti Bark Small Dog Spray Collar, Auto Citronella Dog Collar
Best remote spray

5.Anti Bark Small Dog Spray Collar, Auto Citronella Dog Collar

★★★★☆4.5 (74)
£33.99 save about £26.01

Anti Bark Small Dog Spray Collar, Auto Citronella Dog Collar is our pick for remote spray. Rated 4.5 out of 5. £33.99, one of the cheaper options here. You can see the full specs and photos on the Anti Bark Small Dog Spray Collar, Auto Citronella Dog Collar page.

What we likeAuto Citronella Dog Collar Stop Barking
Citronella Bark Collar with 3 Adjustable Sensitivity & Spray Levels
Anti Barking Dog Colla
Worth knowingCheck dimensions against your space before ordering

If it is not quite right, we stock plenty more citronella bark collars.

Anti Bark Small Dog Spray Collar
Best refills

6.Anti Bark Small Dog Spray Collar

★★★★☆4.5 (74)
£33.99 save about £26.01

This is the one we would point most people to for refills. Rated 4.5 out of 5. £33.99, one of the cheaper options here. Have a look at the Anti Bark Small Dog Spray Collar for the full spec.

What we likeAuto Citronella Dog Collar Stop Barking
Citronella Bark Collar with 3 Adjustable Sensitivity & Spray Levels
Anti Barking Dog Colla
Worth knowingCheck dimensions against your space before ordering

There are other options in our citronella bark collars range too.

Dynavet Small Dog Spray Collar
Best rechargeable

7.Dynavet Small Dog Spray Collar

★★★★☆4.0 (54)
£35.02 save about £24.98

If you want the best rechargeable, start here. Rated 4.0 out of 5. £35.02, so you pay a bit more for the spec. Full details, sizes and photos are on the Dynavet Small Dog Spray Collar page.

What we likeWell reviewed by buyers
Worth knowingRatings a little lower than the top picks

There are other options in our unscented spray collars range too.

Prefer to browse everything? Our full ranges of citronella bark collars, unscented spray collars and spray collars for small dogs have more sizes, finishes and price points than we could fit here.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use PetSafe refills in other collars?

Sometimes, but not always. Check compatibility. Sometimes, but valve designs differ. Check the listing for compatibility before buying, as the wrong can may leak or not fit at all. When in doubt, ask the seller.

Are spray collars legal?

Yes, everywhere in the UK. Yes. Spray collars are legal across England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland, as they do not deliver an electric shock. Only shock or static collars are covered by the English and Welsh bans.

How often do I refill?

It depends on barking. Frequent refilling means the collar is not changing the habit. It depends on how often your dog barks. If you are refilling often, the collar is probably not changing the habit, and a new approach may help.

Is a vibration collar a better choice?

For some dogs. See our vibration vs spray comparison. For some dogs, yes. Vibration collars need no refills and work in all weather. See our vibration vs spray comparison for more. It may suit some dogs.